Suggestion for Subeta Pet Rating
Posted: 09 May 2012 05:16 pm
Right now the Nostalgic and Blacklight pets are rated under "Excluding redraws." In fact, it appears that Nostalgic is also rated as a redraw.
My suggestion is to change the rating system so both Blacklight and Nostalgic are rated as redraws. I know that the Blacklight is technically a colorfill of the Spectrum color, but the Spectrum is itself a redraw. Since neither of these colors are colorfills of the Common pets, both seem more like redraws than colorfills. I think it is more interesting to see which colorfills of the Common are the favorites, because naturally Nostalgic and Blacklight will usually be preferred over them by most people, and that really isn't an interesting bit of data IMO.
My suggestion is to change the rating system so both Blacklight and Nostalgic are rated as redraws. I know that the Blacklight is technically a colorfill of the Spectrum color, but the Spectrum is itself a redraw. Since neither of these colors are colorfills of the Common pets, both seem more like redraws than colorfills. I think it is more interesting to see which colorfills of the Common are the favorites, because naturally Nostalgic and Blacklight will usually be preferred over them by most people, and that really isn't an interesting bit of data IMO.